Skip to main content

Call: 212-233-6400

Risman & Risman, Attorneys at Law

They Laid Off a Group. There Should Be a List of Ages in Your Packet.

By Risman & Risman, P.C. ·

The meeting is eleven minutes long. Someone from HR you have never met reads from a page, says the word “restructuring,” and slides a folder across the table. Severance. A number. A deadline.

You take it home and read the part about money. You skim the release. You do not read the stapled pages at the back, because they look like a payroll printout and nobody mentions them.

Those pages may be the most useful thing in the folder.

This article covers federal law and New York, with a separate note on New Jersey. It is general information, not advice about your agreement.

What the law requires

The Older Workers Benefit Protection Act amended the Age Discrimination in Employment Act in 1990. It says an employer cannot get a valid waiver of your age discrimination claims unless it does certain things first. One of them applies only when severance is offered to a group.

Under 29 U.S.C. § 626(f)(1)(H), where a waiver is requested in connection with an exit incentive or other employment termination program offered to a group or class of employees, the employer must inform you in writing — “in a manner calculated to be understood by the average individual eligible to participate” — of two things:

First, any class, unit, or group of individuals covered by the program, any eligibility factors, and any time limits.

Second, “the job titles and ages of all individuals eligible or selected for the program, and the ages of all individuals in the same job classification or organizational unit who are not eligible or selected for the program.”

Note “eligible or selected.” In a voluntary buyout, the eligible group is often much larger than the group that took it, and you are entitled to see both.

The statute also sets when it comes. The employer must provide it “at the commencement of the period specified in subparagraph (F)” — meaning at the start of your consideration period, not at the end. A list handed over on day forty of forty-five is itself a problem.

When it applies

The common assumption is that this is for big reductions in force. Not exactly.

The EEOC’s regulation says a “program” exists when an employer offers additional consideration for signing a waiver, pursuant to an exit incentive or other employment termination, “to two or more employees.” 29 C.F.R. § 1625.22(f)(1)(iii)(B).

Two can be enough. But the same provision opens by saying the question “will be decided based upon the facts and circumstances of each case,” and notes that programs are typically a standardized package whose “terms of the programs generally are not subject to negotiation between the parties.” Two individually negotiated exits are not automatically a program. A standardized severance formula handed to several people usually is.

The clocks

If severance is offered to you individually, the law requires at least 21 days to consider it. If it is offered as part of a group program, at least 45. 29 U.S.C. § 626(f)(1)(F). So if you were part of a group and your paperwork gives you 21 days, something is off.

You also get at least 7 days after signing to revoke, and the agreement cannot take effect until that period runs. § 626(f)(1)(G). The regulation adds that this one is immovable: “The 7 day revocation period cannot be shortened by the parties, by agreement or otherwise.” § 1625.22(e)(5).

Three qualifications most summaries leave out.

These periods apply to a severance offer. If you are settling an EEOC charge or a lawsuit you have already filed, § 626(f)(2) requires only “a reasonable period of time,” with no 45 days and no revocation window.

The clock runs from the employer’s final offer, and material changes restart it — but § 1625.22(e)(4) also provides that “[t]he parties may agree that changes, whether material or immaterial, do not restart” it. Many agreements contain exactly that term. Check yours before you count.

You may sign early, which starts the 7-day revocation window. But § 1625.22(e)(6) permits that only where the decision is knowing and voluntary and “not induced by the employer through fraud, misrepresentation, a threat to withdraw or alter the offer prior to the expiration of the 21 or 45 day time period, or by providing different terms to employees who sign the release prior to the expiration of such time period.” If you were pushed to sign fast with a threat or a better deal for early signers, that pressure is itself a fact worth recording.

How to read the list

It is usually a table. Job title, age, number selected, number not selected. Here is what to look for.

Ages come one at a time, for both groups. The regulation says ages “should be broken down according to the age of each person eligible or selected for the program and each person not eligible or selected for the program,” and that “[t]he use of age bands broader than one year (such as ‘age 20-30’) does not satisfy this requirement.” § 1625.22(f)(4)(ii). A list showing 40-49 and 50-59 is not what the regulation calls for.

The denominator has to be the whole unit. Employers like to disclose only the people actually considered. The regulation forecloses it with an example: if a ten percent reduction in the Accounting Department will come from the accountants in the bottom third by performance, the employer “still must disclose information for all employees in the Accounting Department, even those who are the highest rated.” § 1625.22(f)(4)(v).

Voluntary and involuntary must be separated. If the employer combines both, it has to present them so the two are distinguishable. § 1625.22(f)(4)(iv). Folding retirements into a layoff list is how a pattern disappears.

Grade levels have to be broken out. Where terminations span established grade levels or subcategories within a job title, “the information shall be broken down by grade level or other subcategory.” § 1625.22(f)(4)(iii).

Then compare the ages of the people selected against the ages of the people in the same unit who weren’t. You are not proving a case on a napkin. You are seeing whether the numbers point anywhere.

The decisional unit

Everything depends on which group the employer discloses. The regulations call it the “decisional unit”: “that portion of the employer’s organizational structure from which the employer chose the persons who would be offered consideration for the signing of a waiver and those who would not.” § 1625.22(f)(3)(i)(B).

Be realistic about which way this cuts. The regulation says that because the decisional unit “is typically no broader than the facility, in general the disclosure need be no broader than the facility.” § 1625.22(f)(3)(ii)(B). A narrow unit is often permissible, not a trick.

Where it expands is when the decision did. Routine Human Resources review to monitor compliance does not change the unit. But “if the regional manager in the course of review determines that persons in other facilities should also be considered for termination, the decisional unit becomes the population of all facilities considered.” § 1625.22(f)(3)(vi). The unit follows where the choosing actually happened.

One honest limit: the regulation says this section governs what must be disclosed and “is not intended to affect the scope of discovery or of substantive proceedings.” § 1625.22(f)(3)(vii). The disclosure is a floor, not a preview of what litigation would produce.

What a defective list is actually worth

Here is where most writing on this overstates, so I want to be careful.

A defect does not automatically void anything. The Supreme Court has described the OWBPA as imposing a strict statutory stricture on waivers, and the statutory elements are mandatory. But the informational requirements in subparagraph (H) use imprecise terms, and courts asked to void releases over them generally ask whether the defect actually deprived the employee of information needed to evaluate an age claim. Technical or minor errors frequently do not invalidate a release — including, in at least one reported decision, a failure to separate voluntary from involuntary terminations and a failure to separately list the ages of those not selected. Whether a defect matters is usually a question of fact.

A defect gives you leverage, and the burden is not yours. Under 29 U.S.C. § 626(f)(3), in any dispute over whether these conditions were met, “the party asserting the validity of a waiver” — the employer — must prove the waiver was knowing and voluntary.

Two limits worth being blunt about.

It only reaches your age claims. If the ADEA waiver fails, the rest of the release generally stands. Your Title VII claims, your state law claims, and your contract claims were released under ordinary contract principles, and the OWBPA does nothing for them.

And the money is not permanently yours regardless. Under 29 C.F.R. § 1625.23(a), you are not required to tender back the severance before filing a charge or a lawsuit, and keeping it does not ratify the agreement. That is real and important. But § 1625.23(c) allows a court, if you ultimately prevail on an ADEA claim, to order restitution, recoupment, or setoff against your award, capped at the lesser of what you recovered or what you were paid. You do not have to return the check to fight. You may see it netted out at the end.

Finally, and this matters: the OWBPA does not give you a right to demand the list. It makes the disclosure a condition of a valid release. There is no separate lawsuit for failing to provide one. If you ask and get nothing, what you have is an argument about the release, not a claim of its own.

Who is covered

The ADEA protects people who are at least 40 years old. 29 U.S.C. § 631(a).

For private employers, it applies to those with twenty or more employees for each working day in each of twenty or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding calendar year. 29 U.S.C. § 630(b).

That threshold does not apply to government employers. In Mount Lemmon Fire District v. Guido, 586 U.S. 1 (2018), the Supreme Court held that § 630(b) establishes “separate categories: persons engaged in an industry affecting commerce with 20 or more employees; and States or political subdivisions with no attendant numerosity limitation.” If you worked for a small village, school district, fire district, or authority, you are covered by the ADEA no matter how few employees there were.

In New York, the State Human Rights Law reaches further than the ADEA in a different way. Executive Law § 292(5) defines “employer” to “include all employers within the state,” with no employee-count threshold — a change effective February 8, 2020. So a twelve-person private employer is outside the ADEA entirely and inside the state age discrimination law. The federal disclosure never had to happen; the claim can still exist.

New Jersey

New Jersey adds something that can matter more than the list.

Under N.J.S.A. § 34:21-2(b), an employer conducting a covered mass layoff or termination or transfer of operations must provide each terminated employee “severance pay equal to one week of pay for each full year of employment,” with an additional four weeks if required notice was short. The statute says that severance “shall be regarded as compensation due to an employee for back pay and losses associated with the termination of the employment relationship, and earned in full upon the termination of the employment relationship.”

And subsection (e): “No waiver of the right to severance provided pursuant to this section shall be effective without approval of the waiver by the commissioner or a court of competent jurisdiction.”

The consequence for a severance agreement is direct. A valid ADEA waiver requires consideration “in addition to anything of value to which the individual already is entitled.” 29 U.S.C. § 626(f)(1)(D). If the only money on the table is the severance New Jersey already required, there is a serious question whether anything was given for the release at all.

The deadline that is actually yours

The 21 and 45 day periods are the employer’s problem. This one is yours.

A charge of age discrimination must be filed with the EEOC within 180 days of the practice, or within 300 days in a state that has its own age discrimination law and an agency to enforce it. 29 U.S.C. § 626(d)(1). New York and New Jersey both qualify, so the practical number is 300 days — running from when you were told, not from your last day. You may not file a suit until 60 days after the charge, and once the EEOC notifies you that proceedings are terminated, you have 90 days to sue. § 626(d)(1), (e).

Spending 45 days deciding and several months investigating is how people lose claims that were good.

What to do

Find out whether you were part of a group. Were others let go in the same action, and were they offered severance too? If so and your packet has no list, note it before the period closes.

Keep the list the day you get it. Scan it. These pages can differ from the version produced two years later.

Count your days, and read the restart clause. Note the date of the final offer, and check whether the agreement says changes don’t restart the clock.

Don’t sign early just to be agreeable. The consideration period exists so someone can look at the thing.

Have the list read with you. Whether the table means anything depends on the unit, the titles, and what the company said about why. That is a short conversation, and it happens before you give up the claim.

The bottom line

When a company lays off a group and asks for a release of age claims, federal law conditions that release on handing you a map of who was chosen and who was kept, with ages, in writing, at the start of your consideration period.

It is one of the few moments in an employment dispute where comparator evidence arrives without discovery, because the alternative is that the release the company wants may not hold.

Read the back pages.

This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Whether a particular disclosure complies with the OWBPA, and what any of it is worth, depends on facts specific to your situation. If you have been offered severance in a group layoff, talk to an employment lawyer before your consideration period expires.