Skip to main content

Call: 212-233-6400

Risman & Risman, Attorneys at Law

New York Bans “Stay or Pay” on December 19. The Date Is the Whole Story.

By Risman & Risman, P.C. ·

It was in the stack you signed on your first day, somewhere between the direct deposit form and the handbook acknowledgment. One page said that if you left before twenty-four months, you would repay the company for your training. Fifteen thousand dollars. Maybe twenty.

You signed it. Of course you did. You had already given notice at your old job.

Two years later you want to leave, and you can’t, because leaving has a price tag you cannot pay.

New York is about to make that illegal, at least for agreements signed from here on. Whether it reaches the page already in your file is a harder question, and it is the one nobody is answering.

This article is about New York law. If you work in New Jersey, different rules apply.

What the law actually does

The Trapped at Work Act adds a new Article 37 to the Labor Law. It was signed on December 19, 2025, substantially rewritten by a chapter amendment signed February 13, 2026, and it takes effect December 19, 2026.

The thing it targets is called an employment promissory note. Labor Law § 1050(3) defines it as any instrument, agreement, or contract provision “that requires an employee to pay the employer, or the employer’s agent or assignee, a sum of money if the employee’s employment relationship with a specific employer terminates before the passage of a stated period of time.”

Notice that the definition is written around what the document does, not what it is called. The one in your onboarding stack goes by friendlier names. Training reimbursement agreement. Education repayment. Retention agreement. The Department of Labor calls them what everyone else does: “stay or pay.”

Section 1052(1) says no employer may require an employee or prospective employee to sign one as a condition of employment, and that “[t]he execution of an employment promissory note as a condition of employment is unconscionable, against public policy, and unenforceable, and any such note shall be null and void.”

The Assembly sponsor was blunt about why. His memorandum in support says employers “have been trapping employees at work” with these agreements, and that “[w]orkers desperate for a job will sign these contractual agreements without the advice of counsel, unknowingly being trapped in a position under the threat of legal action should not complete the terms of the contract.”

That is an unusually honest description of how these documents get signed.

The date is not a formality

Here is the part almost nobody is telling employees.

The Department of Labor has published guidance on the new law. On when it applies, the Department says: “This law becomes effective on December 19, 2026, and applies to new agreements, or new or amended terms in existing agreements, entered into on or after December 19, 2026.”

Read that twice. The Department’s position is that the law reaches agreements signed on or after December 19, 2026. Not the one in your file from three years ago.

I want to be straight about how settled that is, because it isn’t.

The sponsor’s memorandum, describing what § 1052 would do, says it “would also render any existing note unenforceable.” That points the other way. The memorandum was written for the bill as it passed, which took effect immediately and which opened § 1052(1) with the phrase “Beginning on the effective date of this article.” The 2026 amendment deleted that phrase and pushed the effective date out a full year.

So: the agency that enforces the statute reads it as forward-looking. The sponsor who wrote it said it reaches existing notes. The text no longer contains the limiting phrase it once had. No court has decided the question, and the statute is not yet in force.

If you are holding one of these agreements, that is an open question, and anyone who answers it with confidence is guessing. What I can tell you is that the Department’s view is the one your employer will cite, and that it is guidance — not a regulation, and not a ruling.

Section 1052(2) preserves five kinds of agreements. Two of them matter to most people.

Tuition for a real credential. An employer can still require you to repay tuition, fees, and required educational materials, but only for what the statute calls a “transferable credential,” and only if the agreement clears all five of these:

  1. It is a written contract offered separately from any employment contract.
  2. It does not require you to obtain the credential as a condition of employment.
  3. It states the repayment amount before you agree, and that amount does not exceed the employer’s cost for the tuition, fees, and required materials.
  4. It prorates the repayment across the commitment period and does not accelerate payment if you separate.
  5. It does not require repayment at all if the employer ends your employment, unless it ends for misconduct.

A transferable credential, under § 1050(4), is one that is widely recognized in the industry as a qualification for employment, or that demonstrably improves your employability with other employers. The section then excludes two categories outright.

The first is employer-specific or non-transferable training, which covers both instruction in the employer’s own proprietary processes, systems, internal policies, software or equipment, and instruction that “does not qualify the employee for a new occupational title, classification, or industry-recognized credential and instead consists of skillful variations of general processes known to the relevant trade or industry.”

The second is mandated safety and compliance training — anything legally required to maintain workplace safety, “including but not limited to OSHA certifications, sexual harassment prevention, or diversity training.”

Those exclusions do a great deal of work. If what you got was three weeks on their internal system, or a somewhat fancier version of what everyone in your trade already does, it is not a transferable credential, and the exception does not cover it.

Signing bonuses and relocation. Under § 1052(2)(c), an employer can require repayment of a bonus, relocation assistance, or a similar non-educational payment not tied to specific job performance — but not if the employee “was terminated for any reason other than misconduct,” and not if “the duties or requirements of the job were misrepresented to the employee.”

Among the Department’s examples:

  • You take the bonus and resign early. You can be made to repay it.
  • You take the bonus and are fired for misconduct. You can be made to repay it.
  • You take the bonus, and your position is eliminated. You cannot be made to repay it.
  • You take the bonus and leave because the job was not what they described. You cannot be made to repay it.

The remaining three exceptions cover property the employer sold or leased to you where the sale or lease was voluntary, sabbatical terms for educational personnel, and programs negotiated with a union.

Two words that decide most cases

The prohibition reaches notes required as a condition of employment. The Department defines that as an arrangement where keeping or getting the job depends on signing. An agreement that is “truly voluntary and separate from maintaining or accepting employment,” where you could have kept working without signing, is not a condition of employment and is not banned.

Expect that to be the fight. Employers will restructure these as optional benefits you elected. Whether the agreement handed to you with your offer letter was ever truly optional is a question about what actually happened — not about what the form says, and not about whether someone wrote the word “voluntary” on it.

One line from the guidance cuts your way: “There is no express requirement that the agreement be in writing.” A verbal stay-or-pay arrangement is still a stay-or-pay arrangement.

What this law gives you, and what it doesn’t

It does not give you the right to sue. Asked directly whether there is a private right of action, the Department’s answer is no — there is no express private right of action, the Department is the enforcement body, and it issues fines between $1,000 and $5,000 per violation, weighing the employer’s size, its good-faith belief that it was complying, the gravity, and its history.

What you can do is complain. Section 1053(2) provides that an employee or prospective employee aggrieved by a violation “may file a complaint with the commissioner.” And the violation count is not limited to the signing: each person an employer required to sign one, “or against whom an employer seeks to enforce such a note,” is a separate violation. Coming after you on the note is itself the violation.

Then there is the provision that matters most in practice. Section 1053(1) says an employee sued by an employer trying to enforce a note voided by the article “shall be able to recover attorney’s fees upon a successful defense.” These agreements work because fighting one costs more than paying it. Fee-shifting is what changes that arithmetic.

Section 1051 is worth knowing too: the article’s remedies “shall not supersede any other rights and remedies provided by statute or common law.” Nothing here replaces the defenses you already had.

If you already signed one

Assume for the moment the Department is right, and the new law does not reach your agreement. There is still a separate statute that has been on the books the whole time.

Labor Law § 193 controls what an employer may take out of your pay. Section 193(1)(b) says authorized deductions “shall be limited to” an enumerated list, and the items on it are things paid out for your benefit — insurance, retirement, union dues, transit, tuition you owe a school. Recovering what the employer says you owe it is not among them. The Department’s regulations make the point directly: 12 NYCRR 195-4.5 lists prohibited deductions, including “repayments of loans, advances, and overpayments” taken outside the narrow procedures the rules allow, and “fines or penalties for tardiness, excessive leave, misconduct, quitting without notice.”

So a training-repayment charge is not something they can simply subtract from your check.

Two honest limits on that. First, § 193 does contain real exceptions: subdivision 1(c) permits recovery of a wage overpayment caused by a mathematical or clerical error, and subdivision 1(d) permits repayment of genuine advances of salary or wages. Both come with strict written-notice and dispute procedures the employer has to have followed, and an advance on future wages is a different animal from a training charge — but if what you received was actually an advance, it may be recoverable.

Second, § 193 is about deductions. At least one New York trial court held last year that the statute does not stop an employer from going to court to collect money it claims it is owed. That decision involved an alleged overpayment rather than a training note, and it is a trial-level ruling, not binding appellate authority. Still, a payroll deduction and a collection lawsuit are different problems, and § 193 is aimed squarely at the first.

Before you sign anything, and before December 19

If someone hands you one of these with an offer letter, the agreement deserves more scrutiny than the salary does. Ask whether signing is required to get the job, and keep whatever you are told in writing. That will not settle the question by itself — the test is what actually happened — but it is evidence, and right now most people have none.

If you already have one and you are thinking about leaving, pull the document before you give notice, not after. Most of what determines its worth is answerable from the page. What exactly did they pay for? Is it a credential you could carry somewhere else, or their own internal training? Does the number shrink the longer you stay, or is it the full amount until the day the clock runs out? Does it apply if they let you go, or only if you quit?

And if a demand letter has already arrived, don’t sign or agree to anything until someone has read the actual agreement. Making a payment can have consequences for your position that are not obvious at the time, and they are easier to avoid than to undo.

The bottom line

On December 19, New York stops employers from putting a price on your freedom to quit — at least where signing was the cost of having the job. For agreements signed from that day forward, the protection is real. For the paper already sitting in your personnel file, the law’s reach is genuinely unsettled: the Department says it does not look backward, the bill’s sponsor said it does, and no judge has answered.

That uncertainty is not a reason to pay. It is a reason to find out what you actually signed before you do anything else.

This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. The Trapped at Work Act takes effect December 19, 2026, and the Department of Labor’s guidance may change. If you are facing a repayment demand, talk to an employment lawyer about your specific agreement.