Skip to main content

Call: 212-233-6400

Risman & Risman, Attorneys at Law

The Free Complaint Form That Closes the Courthouse Door

By Risman & Risman, P.C. ·

You were fired three weeks ago. You know why, even if nobody said it out loud.

So you start looking. You type something into a search bar late at night and you find the New York State Division of Human Rights. It’s a real government agency. Filing is free. You don’t need a lawyer. There’s a form.

You fill it out. It takes about forty minutes, and you feel better than you have in weeks, because you finally did something.

If your job was in New York, those forty minutes may have just cost you your day in court.

This article is about New York. If you worked in New Jersey, different rules apply.

Filing with either agency closes the courthouse on both of your claims

If you worked in the five boroughs, two separate anti-discrimination laws protect you: the New York State Human Rights Law and the New York City Human Rights Law. They are different statutes, and you can normally bring both.

File a complaint with either agency and you give up the right to sue on either one.

Executive Law § 297(9) says you can sue in court unless you “had filed a complaint” with the Division or “with any local commission on human rights.” Administrative Code § 8-502(a) says you can bring a City law case in court unless you have filed with the City Commission on Human Rights “or with the state division of human rights.”

Each statute closes the door the other one opens. Walk into the State Division and you lose the City claim. Walk into the City Commission and you lose the state one.

The Division is the agency most people find first. So the mistake I see most often is someone filing there, alone, without knowing that the City claim went with it.

This is not a technicality that gets cleaned up later. Courts throw these claims out, in state court and federal court alike.

That does not mean the agency is the wrong choice

For some people the Division is exactly right. It costs nothing, and you do not have to hire anyone: the agency investigates, and if it finds probable cause, its own attorney presents the case at a hearing. It also has real power. Under Executive Law § 297(4), it can order your employer to compensate you for what the discrimination cost you, emotional harm included, and in employment cases against private employers it can order punitive damages on top.

If your damages are modest, if you want this resolved without a lawsuit, or if you cannot find a lawyer to take your case, the agency may be the best door available to you.

Know what is behind the door, though. Under § 297(2), the Division is supposed to decide within 180 days whether there is probable cause to believe you were discriminated against. Courts treat that deadline as directory rather than binding, so in practice it often takes considerably longer. If the agency finds no probable cause, your complaint is dismissed on the papers. There is no jury. You reach a hearing only if the agency decides to take you there.

The point is not that it is the wrong door. The point is that it locks behind you.

Getting back into court is not your call

There are ways back. None of them are yours to take unilaterally.

Under § 297(9), your right to sue survives if the Division dismisses your complaint for administrative convenience — the agency’s own decision that it would rather step aside than decide your case — or for untimeliness, or because it has annulled your election, meaning it formally undoes the choice you made by filing. And at any point before a hearing starts, you can ask the Division to dismiss and annul so that you can go to court.

Ask is the operative word. The agency decides. Section 297(3)(c) gives the Division “unreviewable discretion” to dismiss for administrative convenience, while dismissals for untimeliness or annulled election are expressly “subject to judicial review.” Either way, you are asking rather than electing.

There is also a gap between the two statutes worth knowing about. Untimeliness is on the list of dismissals that preserve your state court claim under § 297(9). It is not on the list in § 8-502(b), which restores the City court claim only after a dismissal for administrative convenience or annulment. Read together, the statutes appear to mean that a dismissal for untimeliness can hand back the state claim and leave the City claim gone.

If you already filed

You are not out of options, and you should not withdraw anything on your own.

Before a hearing begins, the Division can dismiss your complaint and annul your election, which puts you back in court. That is a request rather than a right, but it is one worth making, and the window closes when the hearing starts.

If you filed with the City Commission instead, look at Administrative Code § 8-113(b). It requires dismissal for administrative convenience at your request, provided you ask before the employer has answered and before the Commission has begun investigating or conciliating. That is the closest thing to a guaranteed exit in either statute, and it is available only early. It gets the City claim back into court; whether it also revives the state claim is less settled, because § 297(9) speaks to dismissals by the Division. One more reason to make the request with a lawyer’s help.

Section 297(9) also provides that if the Division annuls your election at your request, your deadline in court is measured by the limitations period in effect when you first filed with the agency. How far that protects you is a question to put to a lawyer on your facts.

One deadline matters more than the rest. If the Division has already ruled against you, Executive Law § 298 gives you sixty days from service of that order to seek review in court. Not three years. Sixty days.

So talk to a lawyer this week rather than next month.

The EEOC is different, and its clock is much shorter

If you filed with the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, that is not the same thing.

Section 297(9) says a complaint filed by the EEOC to satisfy its federal obligations “shall not constitute the filing of a complaint within the meaning of this subdivision.” Section 8-502(a) says a complaint filed with a federal agency and later referred on “shall not be deemed to constitute the filing of a complaint under this subdivision.”

Read those carefully. What is carved out is a complaint the EEOC files or refers. If you fill out and sign your own complaint with the State Division, you have elected — even if it is later cross-filed with the EEOC.

And do not let what comes next lull you. The deadlines below are the state and city deadlines. In New York you generally have 300 days to get a charge to the EEOC, which is a great deal less than three years, and missing it can cost you your federal claims no matter how the rest goes.

The clock

Executive Law § 297(5) requires a complaint to the Division within three years of the discriminatory act. That three-year period applies to conduct on or after February 15, 2024. For earlier conduct the deadline was generally one year — with an important exception: sexual harassment at work has carried a three-year deadline since August 2020. If your situation began before February 2024, do not assume it is too late, and do not assume it isn’t. Ask.

Administrative Code § 8-502(d) gives you three years to bring a City law claim in court, and stops that clock while a complaint is pending at either agency and during any court review of its dismissal. Section 8-502(e) carves out cases where an administrative convenience dismissal came about through the complainant’s own misconduct — but turning down a proposed settlement does not count against you.

Three years feels like forever when you are three weeks out. In my experience it isn’t. Evidence disappears, witnesses leave, memories soften, and the account your employer writes down in month two becomes the one everybody argues about in year two.

Before you file anything, anywhere

Write down what happened while you still remember it precisely. Dates, who was there, what was said, what changed and when. Notes made at the time carry weight that a reconstruction written a year later does not.

Gather what is already yours. Hire paperwork, any reviews or write-ups, your schedule and pay records, the emails and texts that show how you were treated, anything you received about the termination. Send it to a personal email account. Access to a work account usually ends the day the job does.

Then talk to an employment lawyer before you file. We do not charge for that conversation, and many plaintiff-side firms don’t either — ask when you call. What it buys you is the chance to choose your forum instead of discovering it.

The agency form will still be there next week. The City claim might not be.

This article is general information about New York law as of October 2026. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case turns on its own facts, and the law changes. Attorney advertising.

Risman & Risman, P.C. represents employees throughout New York and New Jersey in discrimination, retaliation, restrictive covenant and executive separation matters. If you are deciding where to bring a claim, we are glad to talk it through before you file. 212-233-6400 | www.risman-law.com